Roof Replacement vs. Repair: How to Make the Right Decision

The roof of your house is a key asset, playing a vital role in protecting your property and contributing significantly to its market value. Because of the substantial impact the roof has on the property’s long-term value, savvy homeowners know they must stay involved in regular roof maintenance and upkeep if they want to protect their investment.

That said, even the most responsible homeowner with the most meticulous maintenance routine occasionally runs into unexpected issues or finds themselves in a situation where part of the roof wears out. In some scenarios, a total roof replacement on their Tulsa home is the only option. Other times, it’s possible to make do with a few simple repairs. 

So, how do you know which route to take? Deciding whether to repair or replace the roof is a big deal, and many homeowners shy away from the task because they don’t know how to assess the situation properly. Luckily, Shamrock Roofing and Construction — one of Tulsa’s most trusted roofing companies — is here to help. Here are a few things to consider if you’re trying to decipher what’s best for your home.

Age and Genetics

Any roofing company in Tulsa will tell you that the materials used to manufacture your roof can affect your roof’s longevity. Typical asphalt or composite roofs generally last between 15 and 20 years. Some higher-end materials last much longer. If you notice damage on your roof and it’s close to maxing out its lifespan, your roofer may suggest a total replacement instead of making repairs. On the other hand, if your home is relatively new and your roof is just starting its journey, a few simple repairs may take care of the problem.

Severity of the Damage

Roof damage comes in many different grades, from minor dings and blemishes to missing shingles and flashing. Whether your home has suffered severe wind damage from one of Tulsa’s famous twisters or you’re experiencing a leak after a heavy thunderstorm, it’s essential to have your roof thoroughly assessed by a professional. Any reputable roofing company in Tulsa can offer you a detailed report on the health of your roof and provide direction on whether a repair is feasible or a total roof replacement is more likely. Some roofing companies, like Shamrock, offer free roof inspections to Tulsa homeowners. Get a roof inspection scheduled as soon as you notice the issue. The sooner you catch it, the more likely you’ll be able to prevent it from getting worse.

The Cost 

Of course, cost is always a consideration when determining whether a roof replacement in Tulsa is the right choice. It’s generally more expensive to replace a whole roof than to make repairs. However, if the damage is extensive and located in a spot that requires a complete resection, then replacing the entire roof may be the right solution. 

Along those lines, a detailed assessment of your insurance coverage is also worth your time. Many insurance providers are changing the way they define and cover roof damage. Before making your final decision, you’ll want to know how much financial support you can expect from your insurance carrier.

Need Help Making Your Decision? Shamrock Roofing is Here for You!

When it comes time to weigh the economics of whether to repair or replace your roof structure, you’ll want Shamrock Roofing and Construction on your side. With over 55 years in the roofing business, we’re experts when it comes to this type of assessment. We’ll perform a free roof inspection to determine what’s going on and then help you weed through the options based on our findings. We’re here to make the process smooth and hassle-free. Contact us today!